Scarlatti: 19 Sonatas. Mie Miki (accordion). Vanguard Classics 99193 (1998), Arcade Classics 85551

Domenico Scarlatti: 19 Sonatas. Mie Miki (accordion). Vanguard Classics 99193 (1998) barcode 3351470991938

 

Other edition (reissue?) Arcade Classics 85551 (©1998) 3351470855513:

 

 

Recorded 1-3 September 1997, Nederlands Hervormde Kerk, Renswoude, Netherlands

Scarlatti + Accordion = Great Disc
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 13 February 2014

1. I love the keyboard Sonatas of Scarlatti,
+ 2. I love transcriptions,
+ 3. I love the accordion.

Statement 1 needs no justification, I think. As for transcriptions, my taste may be one of a jaded music lover, but not only: I find that they shed new and often refreshing light on music that you may have heard too much, but also that they often offer new timbral possibilities and seductiveness that have an appeal of their own, independent of how much you’ve heard the composition.

As for my love of the accordion, I find that the instrument offers the best of two worlds: it has all the sharpness of attack and dazzling virtuosity of the keyboard instruments (harpsichord and piano), AND the long breath of the wind instruments, the ability to sustain sound from one note to another rather than fake it through resonance and decay time as with piano and harpsichord. Add to that the unique, lush timbral colors of the instrument. It sounds very much like the organ, but doesn’t have the muddy, over-thick basses of that instrument. Because of all these qualities the accordion is a great instrument for contemporary music, but it turns out to be a great instrument for playing the classics as well, as this disc bears out.

Mie Miki’s recital features a good selection between the most famous Sonatas (K 159 track 4, K 141 track 6, K 9 track 7, K 24 track 8, K 519 track 13) and the more neglected ones, and a fine balance between the lively and the pensive. The fast ones she plays with the required pyrotechnics and the slow ones (10) with fine atmosphere, a true sense of poetry and imaginative use of changes of registers (try track 3 at 1:25). TT is 68:31. This is as fine as any Scarlatti recital – with a plus: the seduction of the instrument. Her choice of Sonatas makes it, I find, a more attractive recital than the similar one by Teodoro Anzelotti on Winter & Winter 910 062-2 (2001) 025091006229 (see my review on Amazon.com pending repost here).

So now, let’s compute:

1. I love the keyboard Sonatas of Scarlatti,
+ 2. I love transcriptions,
+ 3. I love the accordion,

= this is a great disc!

And, if you are into the great classics played on accordion, make sure not to miss (and if you are not, I strongly advise that you try):

Scarlatti 12 Sonatas, Soler 6 Sonatas. Hugo Noth. Editions Guilys GMS 8908 (1989) no barcode

Bach Goldberg Variations by Stephan Hussong on Thorofon Capella CTH 2047 (1988) barcode 4003913120472

Bach Goldberg Variations by Mika Vayrynen on Alba ABCD 191 (2004) 6417513101911

Bach Goldberg Variations by Teodoro Anzellotti on Winter & Winter, 910 170-2 (2010) 025091017027

Bach English Suites 2, 3, 5 by Stephan Hussong on Denon CO-78836 (1995) 081757883627

Bach Partitas 2, 4, three Chorales by Hussong on Denon CO-18031 (1997) 795041803122

Bach Partitas 2 & 4 by Wolfgang Dimetrik on Gramola 98945 (2012) 9003643989450

Bach Inventions and Sinfonias by Janne Rättyä on Castigo 02412 (2000) 4039767000004

Frescobaldi by Stefan Hussong on Thorofon CTH 2349 (1999) 4003913123497 (see my review on Amazon.com pending repost here)

French Baroque Music (Rameau, Couperin, Daquin) by Mie Miki on Challenge Classics CC 72014 (1991, 1997) 608917201420 (see my review on Amazon.com pending repost here), reissue Vanguard Classics 99118 (1997) 3351470991181 (there may be an edition under label Arcade Classics 80556, but I have no trace of it online using what should be its barcode 3351470855568)

Mussorgsky Pictures at an Exhibition by Friedrich Lips (with contemporary works) on Russian Disc RDCD 00204 (1993) no barcode (see my review on Amazon.com pending repost here)

Duos for Classical Accordion: Stravinsky Three Movements from Petrushka, Tango, Mussorgsky Pictures at an Exhibition. James Crabb & Geir Draugsvoll, EMI “Debut” CDZ 5 69705 2 (1997) 724356970526

…for a start.

*********************************************

I see that Mie Miki’s Scarlatti recording has been reissued in a cheap 5-CD box from Brilliant Classics, BRIL96613 barcode 5028421946139, together with other Scarlatti Sonatas played on the harspichord, piano, guitar and harp. I haven’t heard it and don’t know what these other interpretations are worth (by Pieter-Jan Belder harpsichord, Michelangelo Carbonara piano, Luigi Attademo guitar, Godelieve Schrama harp), but I like the principle.

Comments are welcome