Quincy Porter: Symphonies Nos. 1 (1934) & 2 (1962), Poem and Dance (1932). Sinfonia Varsovia, Ian Hobson. Albany TROY 574 (2003) barcode 034061057420

Recorded 3-4 November 2002 at the Witold Lutoslawski Concert Studio of the Polish Radio
Well crafted, expertly and subtly orchestrated, but lacking a truly original and immediately recognizable voice
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 2 February 2007
Born into an old New England family and the grandson and son Yale professors, Quincy Porter (1897-1966) studied at Yale with Horatio Parker, then in Paris with Vincent d’Indy and with Ernest Bloch at the Cleveland Institute for Music where he was appointed to the faculty in 1922. After a subsequent three-year stay in Paris on a Guggenheim fellowship (1928-31), he held various teaching or directing positions in Academia in New York and Boston, culminating in his professorial appointment to Yale in 1946, which resulted in a flurry of compositions and a 1954 Pulitzer Prize along the way. He remained there until his retirement in 1965 and died shortly thereafter.
I discovered the music of Porter through his Second Violin Sonata recorded in 1954 by Louis Kaufman and Artur Balsam and reissued in 1989 on Music & Arts CD 638 (link will open new tab to my review on Discophage.com), with Bloch’s First Sonata). I was surprised by its Bloch-like vigor, unexpected in a composer whose training, career and outlook were, despite being a pupil of the Swiss-born composer, essentially academic and conservative. I decided then to further investigate his compositions – but I find myself slightly disappointed with this disc.
The music is well crafted, often powerful (as in the first symphony’s opening Allegro moderato), pastoral in mood but with sudden outbursts in both symphonies’ slow movements or in the opening “lento” movement of symphony # 2, triumphantly exuberant in the Finale of # 1, and always expertly and subtly orchestrated, even more so in the late, 2nd symphony, which is not based on blocks of sound but on a very gossamer and delicate chamber-music like filigree, sometimes evocative of Stravinsky’s neo-classical style or even Tippett’s symphonic writing.
But unlike these two composers, what Porter lacks in his symphonies, I find, is a truly original and immediately recognizable voice – which is exactly what Hindemith had, whose presence at Yale Porter apparently loathed very much and adamantly opposed. Whether a case of conservatism against modernism (as the liner notes suggest – but Hindemith in that period of his compositional life wasn’t so outrageously modern any more) or of anonimity vs personality, the attitude doesn’t really speak in favor of Porter’s open-mindedness and breadth of outlook.
Still, Albany and Ian Hobson deserve praise for these authoritative recordings of a neglected composer, hardly a major one but nonetheless a fine craftsman well worth investigating by those interested in 20th century American composers.