Read his bio on Wikipedia (link will open new tab): Hindemith’s importance and stature remains disputed. Does he qualify in the super category of “great composers” (even when qualified with an “of the 20th Century”)?
Frankly… I don’t care. I started writing what would have been a long and verbose essay on the significance of the concept of “great composer” – and discarded it. I find it ultimately unimportant to determine if a composer is “great”. I like the music of Hindemith because, throughout the variety of styles he went through, the radicalism of his early days to the conservatism of his later years, it is uniquely distinctive and recognizable, with not only great motoric energy (a trait even more in evidence in the music of his neary-contemporary Bohuslav Martin, 1890-1959), but also harmonic foundations that are uniquely Hindemith’s. And that would be the basis of a definition of “great composer”: a voice and style (or, as in the case of Stravinsky or Ligeti, “styles”) that are uniquely his own, and recognizable within a few bars of “blind” listening or less.
I’ve reviewed so far shamelessly little Hindemith, and I’m not sure why, as I have a sizeable collection of Hindemith CDs. Time…
Sonata for Violin and Piano (1939). Isaac Stern, Alexander Zakin 1946 in Isaac Stern A Life In Music vol. 28 (+ Works of Ernest Bloch and Aaron Copland. Sony SMK 64 533 (1996)
Piano Concerto (1945). Lee Luvisi, The Louisville Orchestra, Lawrence Leighton Smith 1987 (+ works of Donaldson V. Lawhead, Ellen Taaffe Zwilich). First Edition Recordings LCD002 (1990)
Kammermusik No. 2 op. 36-1 for piano (1924), Concert Music for Viola and Large Chamber Orchestra op. 48 (1930), Piano Concerto (1945). Lee Luvisi (piano), Raphael Hillyer (viola), The Louisville Orchestra, Jorge Mester 1968, 1969, Lawrence Leighton Smith 1987 (in Piano Concerto). First Edition Music FECD-0022 (2003)
Wh