Norman Dello Joio: Homage to Haydn, Peter Schickele: Pentangle, Vincent Persichetti: Symphony No. 8. The Louisville Orchestra, Leonard Slatkin (Dello Joio), Jorge Mester. First Edition Encores Albany TROY024-2 (1989) barcode 034061002420

Persichetti recorded 10.III.70 (FECD-0034 indicates XI.70), Dello Joio recorded 14.V.74, Schickele recorded 2.V.79 in Macauley Theatre, Louisville
Dello Joio reissued on First Edition Music FECD-0019 (2003):

Persichetti on First Edition Music FECD-0034 (2005):

Dello Joio and Persichetti nothing special, Schickele more original in its folk-like “neo-simplicity”
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 7 December 2007
As important as the Louisville First Edition Records LPs were for 20th-Century music, releasing, between the early 1950s and the late 1980s loads of music from composers of all stylistic allegiances and nationalities, one of their drawbacks was the lack of coherence of their programs, the apparent motley pairing of composers and compositions with no perceptible stylistic kinship. When Albany picked up the Louisville catalog for CD reissues in the late 1980s (and that went no further than ten releases, followed by ten more made by Louisville’s own label, see my CD-Discography of the Louisville Orchestra for details and links, link will open new tab), to a certain extent they pursued the habit. Some of their releases were indeed devoted to single composers, such as AR011 Walter Piston, AR012 Roy Harris, AR013-4 Morton Gould and TROY 047 Ned Rorem. But this one, TROY024-2, paired composers that didn’t share obvious stylistic or personal ties, other than, at least for Dello Joio and Persichetti, writing music in a very traditional and not highly personal brand of 20th Century modernism. Ironically, though Schickele was indeed a student of Persichetti (and William Bergsma) at Juilliard, his composition is the one that strays most from this tradition – and not surprisingly, it is the most interesting piece on this disc, I find.
Dello Joio’s composition is, as its title implies, a homage to Haydn, to his “seeming simplicity and also good humor” (in the composer’s own words), his “endless imagination”, “the directness of his communication” which, according to Dello Joio, tend to be characteristic of his own efforts. Yes, but: in his time, Haydn was an innovator, an inventor in form and with always some unexpected harmonic twist in his bag of compositional tricks. Dello Joio is not an innovator. Other than a few arresting passages as the mahlerian introduction for strings, his Homage sounds like sophisticated Broadway music, the kind Bernstein might have composed, say, for Candide, or for that matter Sauguet for a Balanchine ballet in the thirties. It is enjoyable, lively, spiky, colorful and easy listening, but hardly memorable. It was written in 1969. It could have been written twenty to forty years earlier. If you want a homage to Haydn that really has something of Grandpapa’s zest and wit as well as much of its composer’s personality, go back to Prokofiev’s Classical Symphony.
Persichetti’s 8th and penultimate Symphony (1967, date not provided in the liner notes) is a more serious statement, but like Dello Joio the composer is so happy to remain way within the bounds of 20th century’s modernist tradition and give no occasion to shock anyone as to make it rather unremarkable. It is well crafted, contrasted, eventful, but ultimately very anonymous. After a slow introduction that starts like Beethoven’s Egmont-Overture and continues in a wistful and brooding mood with horn solo, the fugal and nervously muscular first movement Allegro is at times vaguely reminiscent of Hindemith. The slow movement is soft, appeased and serene – and simply too reliant on the device so time-worn as to be stale of wistful woodwind melody over hushed carpet of strings. The scherzo is busy and rhythmically vigorous, the finale is nervous, rhythmically vigorous again and forward-moving. It is all fine and enjoyable, but all of this has been heard before, with more distinctive personalities, in the symphonies of Schuman, Mennin, Piston and even Harris. And a postscript from July 2008: coming back to Persichetti’s Symphony, seven months later and with score in hand, hasn’t much enhanced my appreciation of it I’m afraid, nor revealed (and both are related) any substantial details that weren’t already obvious on first hearing, other maybe than some of the fine woodwind filigree in the scoring and the strikingly Mahlerian aspect of the scherzo, which on the printed score (but not necessarily in its melodic outcome) looks like a xerox copy. What following the score did reveal is the precision of the Louisvillians’ playing under Mester; some of the music must pose redoutable technical challenges both in individual and ensemble playing for which Mester seems to make no amends in his choices of tempo, and the brave Louisvillians seem unfazed.
With the universal success of PDQ Bach one might easily forget that his inventor, Peter Schickele, was also a “serious”, Juilliard-trained composer. Well, based on his 1976 “Pentangle”, subtitled “Five Songs for French Horn and Orchestra”, the notion of “serious” must be somewhat qualified. The interest and limitation of the piece lies in the simple, folk-like tunes it develops, likening it to a kind of sophisticated orchestration of unsophisticated folk- or pop songs. The composer uses interesting effects, like an echo-dialogue between soloist and the orchestra’s horn (track 5, “Tom on the Town”), or the soloist humming while playing (track 6, “Noonsong”) and even singing (just about as well – meaning, bad – as you and me) an English traditional ballad, “The Riddling Knight”. Whether you will like Pentangle depends, I guess, on whether you enjoy the kind of cross-over approach to classical music which results in Liverpool Oratorios and Pulitzer Prizes being awarded to Wynton Marsalis and Ornette Coleman. Now for a really essential 20th Century composition for horn, singer and orchestra, go back to Britten’s Serenade.
The recordings date from 1970 (Persichetti) to 1979 (Schickele) and come in good sound. TT is a commendable 72:10. For the record, Persichetti’s Symphony had first been issued on LP Louisville LS 706, paired with Wallingford Riegger’s Study in Sonority (a piece I’d like to see reissued to CD); Dello Joio came on LS 742 with Dan Welcher’s Flute Concerto, and Schickele on LS 768 with Joyce Mekeel’s Vigil and Francis Thorne’s Elegy. The Dello Joio piece was reissued in 2003 by First Edition Music, a label established by the Santa Fe Music Group which by then had acquired the Louisville catalog: it came on FECD-0019, coherently paired with the composer’s Triumph of Saint Joan Symphony, one of the earliest Louisville recording, from 1952. Likewise, Persichetti’s Symphony was made available by First Edition Music in 2005 on an all-Persichetti disc, FECD-0034 (with Serenade No. 5, Op. 43 and Symphony No. 5 for Strings, see link above to my review), with the recording date now given as “November 1970”.