Louis Kaufman plays Walter Piston: Violin Concerto No. 1 (London Symphony Orchestra, Bernard Hermann), Aaron Copland: Violin Sonata, Nocturne (Aaron Copland, piano), Ukulele Serenade, Hoe-Down from Rodeo (Annette Kaufman, piano), Robert Russell Bennett: Hexapoda, Five Studies In Jitteroptera (Robert Russell Bennett, piano), Robert McBride: Aria And Toccata In Swing, William Grant Still: Blues from “Lennox Avenue Suite” (Annette Kaufman, piano), Jerome Kern: The Song Is You, Smoke Gets In Your Eyes (Leonard “Tiny” Berman, piano). Bay Cities BCD 1019 (1990) barcode 094659101928

Piston recorded 14 April 1956
Copland’s Violin Sonata recorded winter of 1947/8
Reissues of historical significance, but sonically flawed
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 17 December 2007
Bay Cities was a short-lived label – established in 1989, it folded in 1993 – devoted partly to reissues of orchestral works of Neo-Romantic American composers (Howard Hanson, David Diamond, Randall Thompson…), originated in the CRI, Everest or Desto labels from the 1960s or earlier, and partly to the release of soundtracks from film scores.
For more info on the American violinist Louis Kaufman (1905-1994), see my review of “Historical Recordings of 20th Century American Works” on Music & Arts CD 638 (link will open new tab to my review on Discophage.com). Kaufman was active in the 30s and 40s in the Hollywood studios, where he featured in more than 400 solo film performances. He later quit to embrace a “serious” career, and his main claim to fame was the premiere recording he made of violin concertos from an all-but-forgotten early 18th Century Venetian composer – The Four Seasons of Antonio Vivaldi (reissued in 2005 on Naxos Historical 8.110297-98, link to my review on Discophage.com. Kaufman also premiered a number of notable compositions including concertos by Martinu, Milhaud and Sauguet. He was also an early champion of Barber’s and Piston’s violin concertos. Yet he never acquired a stature and reputation equal to those of the leading American violinists, Yehudi Menuhin, Isaac Stern or even Ruggiero Ricci.
Walter Piston’s Violin Concerto (his first, from 1939; he composed a second one in 1960), with the London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Bernard Herrmann, was apparently recorded on April 12, 1956 (dating from the great LSO discography by Philip Stuart; the Bernard Hermann website indicates April 14), but released only somewhere in the 1970s on an obscure Discopaedia LP (paired with Khachaturian’s). My guess is that, as the same forces’ recording of Robert Russell Bennett’s Violin Concerto from May 19, 1956 (available on another Bay Cities reissue, BCD-1008, with works of Roy Harris), it was used for a BBC broadcast and meant to be issued on LP, but never was, for reasons unclear, one copy remaining in the possession of Kaufman. Be it as it may, what can be heard on the Bay Cities CD is the surface noise pointing to a dubbing directly from an LP. The sound is congested and, had I not read the production info, I would have thought it to be a (good) transfer from 78rpms from the late 1940s.
The initial coupling with Khachaturian’s was appropriate as it is indeed the Armenian composer’s Concerto which Piston’s brings to mind (all the way to a first movement theme which bears a striking resemblance with one in Khachaturian – but Piston’s work was composed first): in its outer movements it has the same kind of colorful, sunny lyricism (the middle adagio is more meditative and intense), also very typical of a score of Violin Concertos composed in those years, including Rodrigo’s (see on Amazon.com pending repost here my review of Christian Ferras’ 1951 recording on Testament SBT 1307 barcode 749677130725), Casella’s, Malipiero’s – both performed by André Gertler on Supraphon Archiv SU 3904-2 barcode 099925390426, link to my review on Amazon.com -, or Milhaud’s 2nd, again by André Gertler on Supraphon 11 1814-2 911 with Enescu’s mesmerizing Violin Sonata No. 3 “in the popular Romanian style”, review on Discophage.com). But Piston’s doesn’t quite have Kachaturian’s (or Rodrigo’s) unique melodic appeal.
Surface noise is more excusable in the case of the recording made by Kaufman for the Concert Hall label, still in the 78rpm era, of Copland’s Violin Sonata with the composer at the piano in the winter of 1947/8, some four years after the completion of the composition. The violinist had given the West Coast premiere in 1944. His recording has an important historical significance, then, representing the composer’s view as the work was still fresh. Copland later re-recorded the piece, with Isaac Stern, in 1968 (now on “Isaac Stern A Life In Music vol. 28” with Sonatas of Hindemith and Bloch, Sony SMK 64 533).
Tempos had significantly broadened by then, exemplifying a tendency that one can observe throughout the history of recordings in the 20th Century (just compare Klemperer’s or Walter’s remakes of Mahler Symphonies, Bersnstein’s Sibeliuses or even Boulez’ Marteau sans Maître). The Sonata is pervaded by the serene and wistful mood of Appalachian Springs, but with traces, in the first movement’s slow-fast construction and especially in the piano part, of the more radical Copland of the Piano Sonata (written only two years before).
The other pieces on this CD are mere lagniappes, the kind of trifle which fit snugly on one side of a 78rpms and appealed to wider audiences: Copland’s bluesy Nocturne (1923) with the composer at the piano, his jazzy Ukulele Serenade written for Samuel Dushkin (1926) and Hoe-Down from Rodeo (composer’s arrangement from 1945) with Annette Kaufman. Robert Russell Bennett, like Copland, studied in Paris with mademoiselle Boulanger but, on his return to the US, became one of the main orchestrators for Broadway. His Hexapoda (“one of the accepted names for the entire realm of insects or bugs”, according to the composer himself), written in 1940, is subtitled “Five Studies in Jitteroptera” and that says in all. The composer is at the piano. William Grant Still’s Blues from his Lennox Avenue Suite, in the violinist’s arrangement, and Robert McBride’s “Aria and Toccata in Swing”, written for and dedicated to Kaufman, need no further explanation than their title, other than to note that Ravel had done that kind of Blues as early as 1927 in his Violin and Piano Sonata, and that Stéphane Grapelli isn’t the inventor of the Dance Jazz to classical cross-over after all. Finally we get Kaufman’s schmaltzy arrangements of two Kern standards, “The Song is You” and “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes”, accompanied by pianist Leonard “Tiny” Berman.
Unlike many of the Bay Cities releases that have come my way, the notes (by Kaufman himself, at least in part) are fine and informative, other than the fact that they do not provide any data on the sources and dates of the recordings. With Stern’s later Copland and the recent Naxos recording of Piston’s two Violin Concerto and Fantasia for Violin and Orchestra (Naxos American Classics 8.559003 barcode 636943900321), this Bay Cities release can have an appeal only on those interested in historical recordings or specifically in the artistry of Louis Kaufman.