Kevin Hanlon, Brian Fennelly, Gunther Schuller. The Louisville Orchestra, Gerhardt Zimmermann, Lawrence Leighton Smith, Gunther Schuller. First Edition Recordings LCD003 (1990)

Kevin Hanlon: Cumulus Nimbus, Brian Fennelly: Fantasy Variations, Gunther Schuller: Farbenspiel – Concerto No. 3 for Orchestra. The Louisville Orchestra, Gerhardt Zimmermann, Lawrence Leighton Smith, Gunther Schuller. First Edition Recordings LCD003 (1990) barcode 034063000325

 

 

Hanlon recorded 13.XI.1982 in Macauley Theatre, Louisville
Fennelly recorded 30.IV.1986, Schuller recorded 27.IX.1988, both in Robert Whitney Hall, Kentucky Center for the Arts, Louisville

 

Three excellent compositions, evocative, dramatic, advanced in musical language without being abstruse
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 1 December 2007

The Louisville Orchestra had a fundamental importance, from the early fifties to the late nineties, in commissioning, recording, and releasing on their own label, Louisville First Edition Records, scores of modern music, from composers of all nationalities and stylistic allegiances. I have no insider’s information, but from what I’ve been able to reconstruct, in the late 1980s Albany published ten Louisville CDs, mixing new material and reissues; in the early 1990s, Louisville published another 10 on their own label, now called First Edition RecordINGs, with only new stuff (for the details, see my Louisville CD-discography, link will open a new tab). Then, apparently, they folded. I think the orchestra went through dire financial straits and got to the brink of bankruptcy. The Louisville catalog was then apparently acquired by the Santa Fe Music Group, who reissued intelligently conceived collections, usually monographs devoted to one composer. But it was the end of publishing new recordings. And now that Santa Fe organization seems to have ceased its operations as well.

One drawback of the Louisville LPs had been the lack of coherence of their programs, the often motley pairing of composers with no stylistic or personal links. That habit continued with the Louisville First Edition Recordings CDs, including the one at hand, LCD003. Among the three composers featured here, only the oldest one, Gunther Schuller (b. 1925) has acquired a significant standing in the American contemporary music scene, both for his contribution to “third stream” and jazz-classical crossover and for his “mainstream” compositions. Among these, I heard recently his 1958 “Spectra” (James Levine conducting the Chicago Symphony Orchestra on Deutsche Grammophon 431 698-2) and “Symphony 1965” on VoxBox2 CDX 5092 “American Orchestral Music”, links will open new tabs to my reviews) and found them to be intelligent and engaging works written in serial idiom. As for Kevin Hanlon (b. 1953) and Brian Fennelly (b. 1937), this is my first encounter with the composers and their music. This is the reason why I didn’t buy this CD upon its release in 1990: unlike some of the other instalments in this series, which showcased major works by major composers (Sofia Gubaidulina’s Pro & Contra on LCD006, Karel Husa’s Apotheosis of this Earth and Monodrama on LCD005, William Bolcom on LCD007, John Corigliano on LCD008), it didn’t seem too promising.

In fact, the three works collected on this CD are excellent, and actually share many stylistic traits (there are also personal ties between some of their composers, as Fennelly was a student of Schuller). They are advanced in their musical language and obviously aware of the compositional techniques and styles prevalent in their days, but without being cutting-edge abstruse, always putting their musical means at the service of great evocative power and fine dramatic flair. Although Hanlon’s intention “was never to convert weather into music”, his Cumulus Nimbus (1978) is an evocative musical depiction of clouds and weather changes. Indeed it starts with an evocative “cloud” of soft sounds reminiscent of Ligeti’s Atmospheres, but soon develops to more stormy weather and rhythmical utterances. There is a passage of quasi Adams-like repetitive music, and Hanlon even resorts to the time-hallowed device of scurrying upward and downward flute scales to depict the storm. The composer was 25 when he completed Cumulus Nimbus, so you can forgive him for his borrowings, especially as it is an evocative and dramatic work, showing a very promising composer. Some 25 years hence, Hanlon doesn’t seem to have really made a breakthrough: a Google search doesn’t yield much (he is still professor at the Meadosw School of the Arts at Southers Mehtodist University), and a search on Amazon yields… nothing, other than the present entry. A pity.

Fennelly is better represented on CD, among others on New World Records 80448-2 (1994) barcode 093228044826, CRI CD 759 (1997) 090438075923, and Albany TROY491 (2002) 034061049128. The language in his Fantasy Variations from 1985 broadly points to Schoenberg, Sessions – and Schuller: rhythmically biting and at times almost square, rich counterpoint, wealth of musical and instrumental “events” that catch the listener’s attention, fine mixture of drama and lyricism, of tension and repose. Upon hearing the piece I immediately orderered two more CDs of his music – the incredibly cheap prices demanded for them didn’t hurt either.

Schuller’s “Farbenspiel (Concerto N° 3 for Orchestra)” is not couched in the serial style of his earlier works. As it title implies (“Play of Colors”), it is a composition about orchestral color in the wake of some Ligeti’s and Pendrecki’s works from the 1970s. It is highly dramatic, evocative and, it seems to me, very accessible. It also displays a fine sense of form, with a first movement (“Chorisch”) based on the grouping of instrumental families and the timbral interplay between these various choirs (and the composer’s own comparison with “the shifiting colors of light reflections on a lake” shows an appropriate kinship with Hanlon’s composition), the second (“Solistisch”) showcasing the various soloists in the orchestra and the third (“Orchestral”) bringing “all the forces of the orchestra together in dense multi-colored, multi-layered aggregates of sounds”.

This disc comes as a nice surprise. The sonics from 1982, 1986 and 1988 are excellent.

 

 

 

Comments are welcome