Joan Tower, Otto Luening, Sofia Gubaidulina. The Louisville Orchestra, Lawrence Leighton Smith. First Edition Recordings LCD006 (1991)

Joan Tower: Island Rhythms, Otto Luening: Kentucky Concerto, Sofia Gubaidulina: Pro et Contra. The Louisville Orchestra, Lawrence Leighton Smith. First Edition Recordings LCD006 (1991) 034063000622

 

 

Tower and Luening recorded 28.XI.90 in Memorial Auditorium, Louisville
Gubaidulina recorded 20.XI.89 in Whitney Hall, Kentucky Center for the Arts, Louisville

Tower reissued on First Edition Music FECD-0025 (2004) 809157000259:

 

 

Powerful works by two women composers and a very corny one by the odd-man out
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 27 December 2007

For all that the LPs from Louisville’s First Edition Records brought to the recorded legacy of 20th-Century music, making available, between the early 1950s and the late 1980s loads of music from living composers of all stylistic allegiances and nationalities, one of their drawbacks was the lack of coherence of their programs, the apparent motley pairing of composers and compositions with no perceptible stylistic kinship. When the label went into CD, at the end of the 1980s, now under the moniker First Edition RecordINGs (and that move yielded no more than ten releases), they partly continued the trend, as the present issue, LCD006, bears witness. Here, Louisville lost an opportunity for at least gender coherence: sandwiched between the two fine compositions of Joan Tower and Sofia Gubaiduliana, Otto Luening is, in all senses of the expression, the odd-man out, all the more so as his Kentucky Concerto from 1951 is so corny as to be embarrassing. Kentuckiana at its most cartoonesque, symphonic music for the barn. Why the orchestra chose to program and record it some forty years after its premiere is to me an enigma. Luening of course is remembered essentially as a pioneer of electronic music. I wonder if it sounds this corny, but with electronic sounds.

It would have been a more coherent, all-woman program had Louisville chosen to put on this disc Zwilich’s Second Symphony, which appears on LCD002 (link will open new tab to my review). Moving slightly backward in time, in the very late 1980s Joyce Mekeel’s “Vigil” appeared on LP LS 768 with Francis Thorne’s “Elegy” and Peter Schickele’s “Pentangle” (only the latter reissued on Albany TROY024-2, the result of a collaboration between the Louisville Orchestra and the Albany label at the end of the 1980s to reissue some of the orchestra’s archive, and which yielded no more than ten CDs – see my Louisville CD-discography for all details and liks). That would have also been a good candidate.

Joan Tower’s 7-minute “Island Rhythms” is a fine orchestral showpiece, dramatic and agitated, couched in a language that is entirely contemporary without being abstruse, with a short and haunting slow middle section with strings rising to their most luminous upper reaches, evoking “an underwater swimmer gradually rising to the water’s surface from a very deep place in the ocean”.

Back when this CD was published, in 1991, Gubaidulina was only starting to be recognized as one of today’s major composers. There had been a valuable but difficult to find MCA CD with various pieces including the haunting Seven Last Words of Christ for cello, bayan (a Russian accordion) and string orchestra (MCA Arts & Electronics AED-68005, barcode 076744800527), and the same recording was released at the same time on a Melodiya CD in Europe but with other couplings (SUCD 10-00109, no barcode), but it is really the Deutsche Grammophon recording of her Violin Concerto “Offertorium” with Gidon Kremer, published two years before this Louisville release (427 336-2, barcode 028942733626), which brought her to wider public attention. Today of course the recordings of her works are so many that it is impossible to follow. “Pro et Contra” is a meandering orchestral piece of wonderful instrumental poetry and evocative power, with sudden and short outburts of terrifying violence. One of the most fascinating aspects with Gubaidulina is the freedom of her style. It is entirely contemporary but also entirely personal, being indebted to the dictums of no school. Growing behind an iron curtain had some positive aspects after all. In the liner notes Gubaidulina acknowledges the influences of Shostakovich and Webern, and this is quite appropriate: Shostakovich and his accessible and sometimes facile effects reaching great dramatic impact, and the cerebral, arcane, terse Webern: in their very contradiction these two influences also seem quite apposite to “Pro & Contra”, in which Gubaidulina aims at reconciling apparent opposite musical poles.

The recordings were made in 1989 and 1990 and come in good sound. TT is 62:30. Good notes, although, surprisingly, they are entirely silent about the fact that “Pro et Contra” was a Louisville commission (I owe this information to the liner notes of a competing recording). The Tower piece can now be found on an all-Tower CD by First Edition Music, FECD-0025, paired with reissues from an Elektra-Nonesuch CD from 1990, 9 79245-2 (links will open new tab to my reviews). Gubaidulina’s Pro et Contra has not been reissued since then, but the composition has had a couple of subsequent recordings, on cpo 999 164-2 (1993) barcode 761203916429 and on BIS CD-668 (1994) 7318590006689, making this one by Louisville perhaps less indispensable; still, I am happy to have it, if only for its value as a first recording, made shortly after the premiere. That Luening’s Concerto hasn’t been reissued probably serves the composer’s reputation better.

Comments are welcome