Henry Cowell: Hymn & Fuguing Tune No. 3, Ongaku, Symphony No. 11 “Seven Rituals Of Music”, Thesis – Symphony No. 15. The Louisville Orchestra, Robert Whitney, Jorge Mester. First Edition FECD-0003 (2001)

Henry Cowell: Hymn & Fuguing Tune No. 3 (1954), Ongaku for Orchestra (1957), Symphony No. 11 “Seven Rituals Of Music” (1954), Thesis – Symphony No. 15 (1961). The Louisville Orchestra, Robert Whitney, Jorge Mester (in Hymn and Fuguing Tune). First Edition FECD-0003 (2001) barcode 809157000037

 

 

Symphony No. 11 recorded 20.VI.54, Ongaku recorded 20.IV.58, Columbia Auditorium, Louisville
Symphony No. 15 recorded XI.61, venue not indicated
Hymn and Fuguing Tune recorded 30.XI.67, The Brown Theatre, Louisville

 

Cowell more original here than I expected – a good introduction to the orchestral composer
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 10 January 2008

I find myself enjoying this disc much more than I expected.

The compositions featured here date between 1954 (Hymn and Fuguing Tune #3 and 11th Symphony) and 1961 (“Thesis”-Symphony No. 15). By then Cowell, the erstwhile trailblazing experimenter in piano sounds, wasn’t so much of an innovator any more, often writing music that was tritely smacking of the American barn-style or sentimental prairie lyricism – and nowhere is this more in evidence than in his Hymn and Fuguing Tunes. Ives did it better, and Ives’ early and more consonant, hymnal style is not what I prefer from this composer anyway. But I am glad to see that Cowell was more original and interesting than that, as a precursor of World Music East-West crossover, but not only.

The 11th Symphony “Seven Rituals of Music” was the first Cowell composition recorded by the Louisville Orchestra, and the usually highly informative production info given by First Edition’s liner notes is false here: the 1959 date attributed by them to the original LP release in fact pertains to Ongaku. The 11th Symphony was recorded in 1954 and came out on LOU 545-2 (not 595-2), the second LP ever released on the Orchestra’s own label, the famous Louisville First Edition Records, part of an initial subscription of twelve. It was paired with Alexander Tcherepnin’s Orchestral Suite op. 87 (now reissued on First Edition Music’s Tcherepnin collection, FECD-0024, link will open new tab to my review) and Bernard Wagenaar’s Concert Overture (not reissued to CD). Actually the Symphony had been recorded by the Columbia team under a joint agreement and also been released as Columbia ML 5039 with Paul Creston’s Invocation & Dance and Jacques Ibert’s Louivsille Concerto (the latter reissued on First Edition Music FECD-1906 “Français Moderne”, link to my review).

Then came Ongaku, in 1959, published with Benjamin Lees’ Second Symphony on LOU 595. “Thesis” (Symphony No. 15) followed in 1961 and came out a year later on LOU 622 with Rodolfo Halffter’s La Madrugada del Panadero-Suite. Finally, Hymn & Fuguing Tune #3 was recorded in 1968 and came out on Louisville LS-682 with Robert Starer’s Mutabiliti and Charles Koechlin’s Five Chorales in Medieval Modes; the LP also had Cowell’s Ballad and his Hymn and Fuguing Tune #2, incomprehensibly and frustratingly not reissued here with its companion. Surely, at 63:26, the CD would have contained it.

The other Cowell composition recorded by the Louisville Orchestra and missing from this CD reissue is the Sinfonietta, recorded in 1968 and released on LS-681 with Carlos Surinach’s Melorhythmic Dramas (the latter now available on and all-Surinach-Louisville First Edition Music FECD-0039 , link to my review). Unless otherwise indicated the pairings mentioned in this review from the original Louisville LPs have not been reissued to CD, but upon repost of this review on Discophage.com in July 2025, they can be found as downloads or on streaming. For more on the Louisville recordings and their CD-availabilty, see my Louisville CD-discography.

I find Ongaku (1957) fascinating in its (to my ears) Japanese genuineness. It doesn’t sound like a Puccini-like, mock Japan deformed through the thick lenses of Western glasses, but like authentic Japanese Court music. The first movement is stately and serene, the second more animated and lyrical, dreamy at times. Both, as Cowell puts it, are strange sounding, but only superficially so, and the result is quite haunting.

The 11th Symphony is also quite original. The “Seven Rituals of Music” are in fact Ritual musics to accompany “the life of man from birth to death”. It starts with “music for a child asleep” and ends with “music of the ritual of death”. The second movement is especially striking and original, a “ritual of work” scored for percussion ensemble, later joined by brass fanfares, maybe the “prophetic hint of war” the composer refers to in his explanatory notes. Unexpected percussion sounds and colors are also much at the fore in the fourth movement, “music for the ritual of dance and play”, in the midst of boisterous American festive music. Otherwise the music is often delicate and eerily mysterious, as in the third movement, “a song for the ritual of love, with the premonition of magic” and even more the fifth movement, “ritual of magic and the mystical imagination”.

Thesis is also remarkable for its formal freedom (five short movements followed by a recapitulation of them in a sixth one and a sonata-form last movement based on an extension of the primary motif uniting the whole) and for some of its orchestral effects: try the “carpet” of violin glissandos which open the second movement, as contemporary as anything written by Penderecki or Karel Husa in those years or later – over which a deep, tonal, recitative-like melody on bass strings develops, or again in the fourth movement the violins playing harmonics over bass pizzicato, turning into flutes against bassoon staccato. These are fine examples of what was so original with the young Cowell, that made his approach to “modernism” so unique and relevant: that he was both traditional in his adherence to tonality and folk-inspired melodic invention, and entirely innovative in his experimentation of unheard piano sounds.

This is an excellent introduction to Cowell the orchestral composer.

 

Comments are welcome