Français Moderne: Arthur Honegger, Jacques Ibert. The Louisville Orchestra, Robert Whitney, Jorge Mester. First Edition Music FECD-1906 (2005)

Français Moderne: Arthur Honegger: Prélude pour Aglavaine et Sélysette (1917), Suite archaïque (1951), Jacques Ibert: La Ballade de la Geôle de Reading (1921), Baccanale (1958), Louisville Concerto (1953). The Louisville Orchestra, Robert Whitney (in Suite archaïque, Louisville Concerto), Jorge Mester. First Edition Music FECD-1906 (2005) 809157190622

 

Louisville Concerto recorded III.54, Columbia Auditorium, Louisville
Suite archaïque recorded “1961”

Prélude recorded 11.II.69 
Bacchanale, recorded “1970”
Ballade recorded 12.XII.73, all in Macauley Theatre, Louisville

Rare stuff by Honegger and Ibert
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 13 November 2007

As I wrote in my review of First Edition Music’s collection of Louisville Orchestra-performed compositions by six Polish 20th Century composers (FECD-1909, link will open a new tab to my review), there is (or was, as alas the company seems to have ceased its operations) a genuine, clever, sensible, cultured and musical mind at work behind these reissues. They represent a welcome break with the time-honored Louisville tradition, as they present highly coherent programs that fit snugly in one’s music library. For all that the Louisville LP releases brought to the recorded legacy of 20th Century music of all schools and styles, one of their drawbacks was their motley programs and apparent haphazard bringing together on a single LP (or CD in the late 1980s and early 1990s – for the details and links, see my Louisville CD-discography) of composers with hardly any stylistic or personal ties. When The Santa Fe Music Group acquired and started releasing the Louisville catalog in the early 2000s on their label First Edition Music, they did so in the form of monographs, discs devoted to a single composer, collating Louisville recordings made at different times and thus usually offering fine overviews of the composer’s development. In some of them, obviously for lack of material in the Louisville catalog, the total time was disappointingly short, anywhere between 40 and 50-minutes, but, at the cheap price demanded for most them on your favorite commercial website, that was a small downside in the face of the coherence and interest of the compilations.

But what to do when there wasn’t enough music of a composer in the Louisville catalog to fill even that? Well, the mastermind in charge of artistic decisions at First Edition has cleverly and tastefully gathered four well-filled collections devoted respectively to “British Modern” (FECD-1904 with compositions of Addison, Arnold, Bliss and the superb Improvisation for Violin and Orchestra of Rubbra), Polski Nowaczesny = Polish Modern (see above), “Magyar Modern” (FECD-1911, Kodaly, Antal Dorati as composer and Mathias Seiber – links will open new tab to my reviews) and this one, “Français Moderne”.

The two Honegger compositions here included are not among the composer’s most famous and typical, but their interest lies precisely in the fact that they are seldom-performed and recorded pieces of their author. The Prelude to Aglavaine et Sélysette (1917) is Honegger’s first orchestral composition, and is couched in a language reminiscent of Debussy’s Pelleas – not unfittingly, as the play is also one by Maeterlinck.

Suite Archaïque is a late piece (1951) and a Louisville commission. The hallmarks of Honegger’s most serious style are present. The outer movements are slow-moving, brooding chorales with trumpet solo in the first. The second movement (“Pantomime”) is interesting and quite typical with its flute flattertongue effects and sardonic trumpet, the 3rd movement (“Ritournelle et Serenade”) displays a plaintive solo cello harking back to the cello concerto, whose line is then picked up by solo violin.

It was fitting to pair Jacques Ibert (1890-1962) with Honegger (1892-1955), as both composers belong the same generation. “The Ballad of Reading Gaol” was the composition that first brought public notice on Ibert when it was premiered in 1922 by the Concerts Colonne under Gabriel Pierné. It is a substantial composition (25+ minutes), deploying all the resources of a musical impressionism in a style reminiscent of Ravel’s Daphnis & Chloé or Dukas’ Sorcerer Apprentice rather than Debussy (although there are whiffs of La Mer in the 3rd movement). The mood is sombre and dramatic as befits the subject, but with escapes evocative of the Day’s Awakening in Ravel’s Daphnis (8:37 into the first movement for instance), as if the prisoner Oscar Wilde was gazing through the window of his cell, with dreams of liberty. Good 1973 stereo sound.

The 1958 Bacchanale – a Louisville commission – is to Ibert what the Sabre Dance from the ballet Gayaneh is to Aram Khachaturian. As with the Armenian composer’s warhorse, it is a flashy and vulgar showpiece. Surprisingly, though the 1970 stereo sound is quite good, I hear slight clicks, as if the transfer had been dubbed from an LP rather than, as stated in the production info, directly from the master tapes. But it is nothing you will notice without headsets.

The 1953 Louisville Concerto is again a Louisville commission and was one of the earliest Louisville releases (545-5), part of a batch in 1954 that included twelve LPs (Otto Luening and Vladimir Ussachevsky’s pioneering Rhapsodic Variations for Tape and Orchestra was on the same LP – brave Louisvillians and brave Robert Whitney, and what a great tribute to Louisville’s eclecticism). The Concerto is a boisterous orchestral showpiece, going through a variety of moods and colors in typical Ibert style, but the mono 1954 tape doesn’t allow to fully enjoy its colors, all the more so as it appears somewhat worn, with a constant left-right channel fluttering.

As with the other discs mentioned above this one is well-filled (67+), and has fine notes, including those from the original LPs. This release was labelled “français moderne vol. 1”. If my suspicion is right that First Edition Music has now folded, it is sad to think of all the rare French music – André Jolivet’s Suite Transocéane, Charles Koechlin’s Cinq Chorals dans les modes du Moyen Age and Partita, Henri Sauguet’s Les Trois Lys, Francis Poulenc’s Deux Marches et Un Intermède – that will remain hidden in the Louisville vaults and second-hand LP sellers.

And a postscript from January 2012: good news/bad news. The good news is that Louisville and the Santa Fe Music Group are back in business, and they seem to have finally released the complete Louisville catalog. The bad news is that it is on download only. Go to downloads and type Louisville Soundmark, it yields 58 results, some the straight reissues of the corresponding CD, but most new (and clever) compilations. And a postscript from 2025: Those include indeed a collection titled “Français Moderne vol 2” with all those pieces mentioned above… and more, by Marcel Grandjany and Ernest Guiraud.

Comments are welcome