Enescu: Violin Sonata No. 3, Szymanowski: Notturno e tarantella, Prokofiev: Violin Sonata No. 1, Ravel: Pièce en forme de Habanera, Tzigane. Yehudi Menuhin. EMI Références 5 65962 2 (1996)

Yehudi Menuhin. George Enescu: Violin Sonata No. 3 op. 25 (Hephzibah Menuhin), Karol Szymanowski: Notturno e tarantella op. 28, Prokofiev: Violin Sonata No. 1 op. 80, Ravel: Pièce en forme de Habanera (Marcel Gazelle), Tzigane (Artur Balsam). EMI Références 5 65962 2 (1996) barcode 724356596221

 

 

Tzigane recorded 20 & 23 May 1932, Paris
Szymanowski recorded 21 December 1935, Studio Albert, Paris
Enescu recorded 6 January 1936, Studio Albert, Paris
Habanera recorded 6 April 1943, No. 3 Studio, Abbey Road, London
Prokofiev recorded 30 September & 1 October 1948, No. 3 Studio, Abbey Road, London

An invaluable historical document, and an indispensable one for any admirer of Yehudi Menuhin
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 29 June 2007

This marvellous compilation, published in 1996 by Emi “Références”, is a welcome reminder not only of how talented young Yehudi Menuhin was in those early years, with unblemished purity of tone (later on, perhaps through some weakening of the bowing arm, his tonal production sometimes acquired an uningratiating wiriness), but also of his unflinching involvement with the music of his time. He was closely related to another composer not featured here, Ernest Bloch (who wrote his Abodah for the 12-year-old Menuhin, as well as the late Solo Violin Suites), and to Enescu, whom he studied with. Later of course he became a champion of Bartok.

Featured on this disc is the first recording ever of Enescu’s magnificent 3rd Sonata “Dans le caractère populaire roumain” (In the Rumania Folk Character) from 1926. According to the notes, Menuhin and his sister Hephzibah had secretly learnt the piece and played it as a gift to the composer. Enescu, who besides being a composer was one of the greatest violinist of his time, later twice recorded the Sonata, once in 1943 with Dinu Lipatti (briefly available on a 2 CD-set from the Philips Legendary Classics series, 426 100-2 barcode 028942610026) and again with Céliny Chailley-Richez (dates differ, probably 1948). The Menuhins also re-recorded the Sonata, 30 years after their first essay, as a complement to Menuhin’s collaboration with Ravi Shankar (reissued to CD by a label called Beat Goes On Records BGOCD445, link will open new tab to my review on Discophage.com).

With the “Impressions d’Enfance” (1940), also for Violin and Piano, the Sonata is possibly the composer’s towering masterpiece, equal to anything that was written for these two instruments in the first half of the 20th Century. There, the composer invented a uniquely personal sound-world, inspired by Rumanian Gipsy music, rhapsodic and whimsical, and displaying a wide array technical effects used for their unique coloring and expressive possibilities: trills, mordents, acciaccaturas (also in the piano writing, lending it a unique, “aquatic” quality), upward portamentos, quarter tones, harmonics, non vibrato playing, sul ponticello (on the bridge), striking with the tip of the bow. Not surprisingly, the Menuhins turn out a reading that is stylistically very close to the composer’s own with Lipatti, though more spacious in the brooding passages, but as playful as him in the more animated ones. In the second movement, Menuhin is more spacious than in his 1966 remake and, above all, infinitely superior to his future self in the beauty of his tone production. The two partners hurl enthusiastically into the finale, with a tempo that is faster than the composer’s own, losing along the way some of the music’s rustic flavor. Only in the final page does Menuhin sacrifice some beauty of tone for the sake of raw expressivity. This is of course no hi-fi sound, though everything comes out very clearly, and it remains an invaluable historical document.

I bought this disc for the Enescu and to me all the rest is bonus. It is great to have Menuhin playing (with Marcelle Gazelle in 1935) some Szymanowski (the only that he recorded), although the “Nocturne and Tarantella” op. 29 isn’t as mesmerizing and original as the Composer’s “Mythes” op. 30. Menuhin, quoted in the liner notes, recounts that he received a copy from Prokofiev’s Sonata from the hands of David Oistrakh when it was barely finished. It had been premiered in Moscou by Oistrakh and Oborin, and in the US by Joseph Szigeti, but apparently this version by Menuhin and Marcelle Gazelle was the first to be committed to disc. It is Menuhin’s only recording of it, and of any Prokofiev.

The same holds true with the 1932 recording of Ravel’s Tzigane with Artur Balsam – Menuhin’s only recording of that piece and yet another link to Enescu, as Menuhin learnt the piece with the Rumanian composer and, quoted again in the notes, claims that “he played it like no-one else, but this is almost the way he played it”. It is again a stupendous reminder of Menuhin’s technical proficiency in those years, and a lesson in giving Gipsy life and swagger while still precisely observing Ravel’s rhythms and technical effects. Menuhin practices three cuts however, two of them in some transitional passages for piano alone but one excising 10 measures with violin, at 7:07.

Nonetheless this is an invaluable historical document, and an indispensable one for any admirer of Menuhin.

Comments are welcome