British Modern vol. 1: Arthur Bliss: Discourse for Orchestra (Robert Whitney), Edmund Rubbra: Improvisation for Violin and Orchestra (Sidney Harth violin, Robert Whitney), Malcolm Arnold: Concerto for Two Violins and String Orchestra (Paul Kling, Peter McHugh violins, Jorge Mester), John Addison: Concerto for Trumpet Strings and Percussion (Leon Rapier trumpet, Jorge Mester). First Edition Music FECD-1904 (2005) barcode 809157190424

Improvisation recorded X.55, Columbia Auditorium, Louisville
Discourse recorded XI.57, Columbia Auditorium, Louisville
Trumpet Concerto recorded 9.V.69, Macaulay Theatre, Louisville
Concerto for Two Violins recorded 5.II.73, Macaulay Theatre, Louisville
Rubbra’s Improvisation the prize of this collection, Arnold’s Concerto for Two Violins an enjoyable piece too
Originally posted on Amazon.com, 13 November 2007
As I wrote in my review of First Edition Music’s collection of Louisville Orchestra-performed compositions by six Polish 20th Century composers (First Edition Music FECD-1909 – link will open new tab to my review), there is (or was, as alas the company seems to have ceased its operations) a genuine, clever, sensible, cultured and musical mind at work behind these reissues. They represent a welcome break with the time-honored Louisville tradition, as they present highly coherent programs that fit snugly in one’s music library. For all that the Louisville LP releases brought to the recorded legacy of 20th Century music of all schools and styles, one of their drawbacks was their motley programs and apparent haphazard bringing together on a single LP (or CD in the late 1980s and early 1990s – for the details and links, see my Louisville CD-discography. Link will open a new tab) of composers with hardly any stylistic or personal ties. When the company called The Santa Fe Music Group acquired and started releasing the Louisville catalog in the early 2000s on their label First Edition Music, they did so in the form of monographs, discs devoted to a single composer, collating Louisville recordings made at different times and thus usually offering fine overviews of the composer’s development. In some of them, obviously for lack of material in the Louisville catalog, the total time was disappointingly short, anywhere between 40 and 50-minutes, but, at the cheap price demanded for most of them on your favorite online commercial website, that was a small downside in the face of the coherence and interest of the compilations.
But what to do when there wasn’t enough music of a composer in the Louisville catalog to fill even that? Well, the mastermind in charge of artistic decisions at First Edition has cleverly and tastefully gathered four well-filled collections devoted respectively to “Français Moderne” (FECD-1906 with compositions of Honegger and Ibert), “Polski nowaczesny” (see above), “Magyar Modern” (FECD-1911, Kodaly, Antal Dorati as composer and Mathias Seiber – links will open new tab to my reviews) and this one, devoted to four British composers and totalling a commendable 67:30 minutes. All the compositions gathered here are stylistically conservative: the musical language doesn’t go beyond Shostakovich and Prokofiev, which doesn’t mean the compositions do not afford genuine musical pleasures. They are all premiere recordings by the way.
As Malcom Arnold, John Addison was mainly active as a composer of film music, but unlike the former he didn’t really establish a reputation in concert music. His Trumpet Concerto is an unsubstantial and light-hearted piece that could have been written by Poulenc at his lightest, although it becomes quite foot-lifting in its scurrying finale. Pleasant, but not memorable. Good stereo sound from 1969.
Bliss’ Discourse for orchestra, a Louisville commission premiered in October 1957 and recorded shortly after, is a sort of variation, or elaboration upon a rather dramatic motif based on simple intervals heard at the outset, subjected to a variety of moods and considerations corresponding to the composition’s six movements and titled respectively “a preliminary view”, “a more disturbing view”, “a gayer one”, “a contemplative one”, “an emphatic statement of the subject”, “A peroration followed by a quite close”. Bliss withdrew the piece after its Louisville premiere and substantially reworked it (including a complete removal of the 2nd section), so this is the only recording of the first version. That said, the music is not as interesting as the piece’s description. It is couched in the late-Romantic to timidly modern musical language so typical of British composer of that generation, and nowhere as personal as Vaughan Williams’. And maybe Bliss suppressed the 2nd section because it sounded so much like Roussel’s symphonies or ballets. The third sounds like Strauss. The fourth includes solo statements from the strings of heart-on-sleeve and somewhat sentimental lyricism, the fifth is agitated and dramatic but ultimately hollow, the finale goes for the grandiose and doesn’t avoid the bombast. As mentioned, the sound is 1957 mono.
Arnold’s Concerto for Two Violins breaks no new ground but it is a pleasant work, rather dramatic in its dynamic outer movements (combined with an engrossing lyricism reminiscent of Prokofiev’s Violin Concertos in the finale), and intensely lyrical in the 2nd – a worthy successor of the Vivaldi concertos written for the same combination of instruments. Peter McHugh and Paul Kling play with fine tone. Good stereo sound from 1973.
But to me the prize of this collection is Rubbra’s 12+ minute Improvisation for Violin and Orchestra. A Louisville commission from 1955, it has the brooding intensity of Shostakovich’s Violin Concertos and the radiant lyricism of Bartok’s First Violin Concerto. Its only problem possibly is that it was written in 1955 rather than thirty years earlier (Bartok’s First dates from 1907-08). But then, so what? Shostakovich’s First Concerto was written only a few years before (1947-8) and the Second is a late work from 1967, and that they are not “modern” is of no importance in view of their expressive intensity. Returning to Rubbra’s Improvisation a few years after writing this review, upon having found a used study score, it strikes me as one of the great unknown 20th masterpieces for violin and orchestra. Fiddlers, wake up!
The premiere performers, recorded immediately after the world premiere, give an intensely committed performance, and that the 1955 mono sonics place the orchestra in a more distant position does not impair enjoyment. And this is not the first time I hear it (see my review of FECD-0007 Wallingford Riegger): why isn’t Sidney Harth recognized as one of the major violinists of the 20th Century? No kidding: in purity of tone and expressive intensity, Harth is easily in the league of Oistrakh and Stern. As good as is the recent Krysia Osostowicz on Naxos 8.557591 (2005) 747313259120 (with Rubbra’s Violin Concerto and Improvisations on Virginal Pieces), her tone is thiner and her playing isn’t as throbbingly intense. Harth was 30 when he recorded the Rubbra. Why didn’t he make it to a more prominent career? The man (he died in 2011) had all the credentials required: Naumburg award and first American to receive the Second Prize in the 1957 Wieniawski Violin Competition held in Poland. Maybe because he chose the safer life of a concertmaster, with the New York Philharmonic, Chicago Symphony (it’s him who plays on Reiner’s Scheherazade), LA Philharmonic and Louisville Orchestra.
The notes are those of the original LP editions, with a new general introduction to these four composers.
And a postscript from January 2012: good news/bad news. The good news is that Louisville and the Santa Fe Music Group are back in business, and they seem to have finally released the complete Louisville catalog, or at least another step in that direction. The bad news is that it is on download only. Go to downloads and type Louisville Soundmark, it yields 58 results, some the straight reissues of the corresponding CD, but most new (and clever) compilations.