Arnold Schoenberg (1874-1951, Austrian)

I’m going to be lazy and just quote an excerpt of Schoenberg’s entry on Wikipedia:

“Writing in 1977, Christopher Small observed, ‘Many music lovers, even today, find difficulty with Schoenberg’s music’. Small wrote his short biography a quarter of a century after the composer’s death. According to Nicholas Cook, writing some twenty years after Small, Schoenberg had thought that this lack of comprehension

was merely a transient, if unavoidable phase: the history of music, they said, showed that audiences always resisted the unfamiliar, but in time they got used to it and learned to appreciate it… Schoenberg himself looked forward to a time when, as he said, grocers’ boys would whistle serial music in their rounds. If Schoenberg really believed what he said (and it is hard to be quite sure about this), then it represents one of the most poignant moments in the history of music. For serialism did not achieve popularity; the process of familiarization for which he and h is contemporaries were waiting never occurred.”

 

Well, I for one can whistle tunes of Schoenberg, and not just out of Transfigured Night. Still, I understand and accept that this is an exception and probably won’t ever become a rule, as I understand and accept that the music of Schoenberg (or Boulez, or Xenakis, Stockhausen, Ferneyhough, Babbitt…) is not likely to ever gain general acceptance among the music-going public

But I’ve also noted, in the last decades, the brazen surge of the neo-Beckmessers (a “Philistine” is truly ignorant; Beckmesser has education and knowledge, but puts it at the service of his reactionary views, and uses it to confirm, not challenge, his reactionary biases), conservatory-trained commentators who believe it fit to lash out at Schoenberg’s music and deride it – one of the latest being French intellectual and politician Jacques Attali (link to Wikipedia), the author in 1977 of the book “Bruits” (“Noise: The Political Economy of Music”) and one of those politicians who dabbles into conducting, apparently unaware of how much he is ridiculing himself in the eyes of trained classical musicians (the bliss of ignorance!), and he ridiculed himself even more back in 2015 in an online interview in which he stated that atonality was “music terrorism”, seemingly throwing to trash one of the most abundant and most innovative portion of music composition since the early 20th century.

“La seule chose qui me semble ne pas avoir de sens c’est la musique lorsqu’elle sort de la « grille harmonique ». Je crois personnellement que la musique atonale est une impasse, elle ne correspond pas à la nature même de l’audition, elle a constitué une tentative de « terrorisme musical » qui ne correspond pas à la nature profonde de ce qu’est la musique.” 

(The only thing that seems to me to be senseless is music when it steps out of the ‘harmonic grid’. I personally believe that atonal music is an impasse, it doesn’t correspond to the very nature of audition, it represented an attempt at “music terrorism” that doesn’t correspond to the profound nature of what music is.)

Because, of course, “savant” Jacques Attali would know better than generation after generation of composers and performers…

And why am I limiting this emboldenment of the neo-Beckmessers to the last decades. It started with conductor and Stravinsky-champion Ernest Ansermet, who tried to demonstrate that serialism was “anti-natural” and therefore impossible (see the relevant paragraph in Ansermet’s entry on Wikipedia, that shows that Ansermet didn’t shy of antisemisism either), and only succeeded in ridiculing himself in the eyes of posterity.

Hey guys: disliking the music of Schoenberg (or Xenakis, Boulez, Stockhausen, Babbitt) is okay, no issue with that. I’ve expressed my doubts with some works of Boulez (see my review of Structures for 2 pianos – link will open a new tab) and many works of Babbitt – hell, I’ve even substantially questionned the whole rationale of Babbitt for giving little care “if you listen”, or at least “if you appreciate” (see my Babbitt page).

But please: blame your dislike on your own limitations – in knowledge and understanding, for all your conservatory training. You really think that you are more knowledgeable, more clever, more understanding than generations of equally conservatory-trained musicians who have endorsed and appreciated atonal music? How bold… or how dumb? Say “I don’t understand it, and therefore don’t appreciate it”, rather than “It’s shit”. And you could even add: “and I’ll try to return to it and make an efffort at understanding and appreciating it”. I’m not particularly fond of the music of Richard Strauss (with some exceptions), but I acknowlege that generations of great musicians – including Glenn Gould, for whose intelligence, wit AND musicianship I have the greatest admiration – have heaped praise and expressed utmost admiration for the music of Strauss, so I recognize that any limitation comes from me, not Strauss, and I’ll return.

We like to believe that knowledge fosters understanding, that it opens the mind and the eyes and the ears. But this is an illusion. We have too many examples where knowledge only serves to justify and reinforce bias, prejudice and intellectual laziness.

The “strictures”, “tyranny” or even (oh Jeeezus, the collapse of intelligence when words are bandied irrespective of their meaning) “terrorism” of atonality and serialism? Come on, give me a break! Jacques, you “terrorized” by atonaly, truly? As Stalin said of the Vatican: “serialism, how many divisions?”. If ever a composer felt that serialism was a tyranny upon him, it only shows how weak in his beliefs that composer was. And we’ve seen so many who, “liberating themselves” from the “tyranny of the avant-garde”, turned from composers with something interesting to say, to churners of stale, reashed neo-romantic drivel. As if everything and anything that came to their mind was worth penning on the music sheet. I once, decades ago, read a quote that, in my memory, was attributed to George Bernard Shaw, but that I’ve never been able to retrieve and confirm, to the effect that “creating” as essentially about “throwing to trash”.

Okay, so I needed to vent that. Bottom line: I’ll keep listening to and reviewing the music of Schoenberg. No problem to me if the neo-Beckmessers don’t – their limitation and their loss. But can they shut up about it, rather than shamelessly flaunt their limitations and ridicules?

For the time being, I’ve reposted here two old reviews from Amazon.com of two excellent versions of Transfigured Night – orchestral version (not Schoenberg most difficult music, to be sure – but more eventually to come, I hope):

Schoenberg: Transfigured Night, Vaughan Williams: Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis. Strings of the New York Philharmonic, Dimitri Mitropoulos March 1958. Sony Japan SRCR 8463 (1991), Sony Japan SRCR 1702 (1996) 

“Transfigured Notes”: Schoenberg Transfigured Night, Babbitt Transfigured Notes, Stravinsky Concerto in D. String Orchestra, cond. Gunther Schuller 8-9 February 1991. GM Recordings GM2060CD (1998)

 

 

Comments are welcome